Monday, June 1, 2020

A Punching Widow and a Black-Eyed Judge: a Problem Parable ont the Problem of Prayer ~ Luke 18:1-8 (Short Stories Jesus Told)


The parables should disturb us. 

They certainly disturbed many of their original hearers. The challenge, of course, is that like so many things we have Disney-fied them – you know, made them sweet and cuddly with happy endings about people far more beautiful than us from a spiritual world far, far away. Most people aren’t aware that many of the Disney films like Cinderella, the Little Mermaid, Sleeping Beauty, Snow White, Beauty & the Beast, etc., were far darker tales originally than many of us imagine – rarely ending in “happily ever after” or without serious tragedy, violence, and pain. They sought to offer a moral vision even as they entertained but did so with greater grit, irony, and on-the-ground-realism than their Disney counterparts. They are “disturbing” but far more powerful. Jesus’ stories are also often like this and we must be careful to not turn them into “la la la, pie in the sky, cutesy” fables. They were by their very nature: apocalyptic. That is, they sought to show us the kingdom often by “unmasking” us and helping us see, which if you been in the dark long enough – can cause your eyes to hurt. And to be honest – this week’s parable maybe one of the more painful stories. It’s the parable of the punching widow and the black-eyed judge (I know that’s not its Disney title)! What does it reveal and unmask? How does it hurt? What does it want us to see?


 Don’t be like her because God’s not like him. [Reading One]

This is an anti-hero story, of sorts. Remember the parable of the unjust steward Luke 16:1-13)? Sometime Jesus would use negative or controversial characters to make a stronger point through comparison and contrast. This is such a story. And because of that – some try and make it nicer than it actually sounds. It’s a story about a widow – we don’t know much about her other than that she comes repeatedly to an unjust judge for help. What she wants is not as clear as it sounds? In fact, this whole parable belongs in the Greek of the Week of the category. Let me explain. The NIV says that the widow wants “justice” but it’s not the regular word for it in the NT and can mean either “vengeance” or “vindicate” or “punish”. It’s a polyvalent word, and, therefore, ambiguous. Paul, for example, will say in Romans 12:19 that it’s something that we should not do – “Do not take revenge [ekdikeō],” he commands. Moreover, the woman, rather than being meek or mild, apparently has threatened the unjust judge because he changes his mind due to her potential violence (vs. 5). The NIV says “attack” but the Greek word is literally a compound word meaning “below the eye.” It’s a boxing term and means to give someone a “black eye”. Apparently, she’s got quite the right hook. BUT – her persistence and potential punches are effective and she gets what she wants. And she has to be tough - consider the judge. The judge, of course, is even less a shining model than the punching widow. The judge, who Jesus calls “unjust” in vs. 6 neither “fears God nor cares for people” (vs. 2). BUT even an unjust judge, Jesus shows, can be persuaded, worn down, beaten into submission. Even he can grant one’s request. And that’s the ironic point. In the end, Jesus doesn’t even refer back to the woman at all. But in vs. 6 says, “Listen to what the unjust judge says.” Why? Well, because he gave her what she wanted and God is not like that. We don’t pray to that God, Jesus implies. We pray to the Father of the two sons who will not “put us off”, the Vineyard owner who is lavishly generous, the one who is always compassionate. So one of the things that Jesus is stating is that “theology matters.” What you think about God matters and will change the way you pray? You don’t pray to a distant, arbitrary, heartless, calculating judge. You pray to a Father that runs. Imagine what he will give and bring in response to your prayers – even when you have to wait. It’s interesting that when I meet with people who are in real distress they often cannot pray. And the reason for this is not some unwillingness on their part but sometimes a bad theology about God who they believe wants to punish them for sport. I often say, “Don’t pray to that God.,” but perhaps I should tell them as Jesus did – even bad judges can be one over so how much more can a father who loves you? You don’t have to punch God in the eye. You don’t need to threaten God to be good. Pray with the knowledge that God is good so justice will come.
Here’s the thing. God is not like the unjust judge. This is a freeing reality in that if God is a good father you can plead and beg in prayer but don’t have to. If God is just you can use words that are ambiguous or problematic, even violent, and God will still listen. 


Wait! I changed my mind. I am the widow and do want to punch God.[Reading Two]
And yet . . . maybe the story is even darker and unmasks us in other ways. Maybe we are more like the widow than we first imagine and that God is the judge that we do want to be violent toward. How often in my prayers are my motives mixed? I do want vengeance and justice to go together – because I am the hero of my story and others are the villain. I want others to pay. And I do get upset with God and want God to avenge me. The fact of the matter is that the drama of the Gospels show us wanting vengeance and not getting a God or Savior we want. I’m reminded, in other words, that God came to us through Jesus Christ, offered us grace, showed us sacrificial love, commanded of us generosity to enemies and sinners, and we got violent. God did let us punch him in the eye. We even did more than that. So another way to read the parable is that even when we do our worst, put up our dukes and make our threats – God still loves us and grants us justice anyway. Perhaps the parable unmasks our prayers for vengeance and God’s willingness, despite our threats, to give us something better, something greater. 


But wait! I changed my mind again. What if I am not the widow at all but the “adversary” (vs. 3)? [Reading Three]
Friends, this week I watched in utter disbelief and horror as George Floyd was murdered by a police officer who crushed his neck. And then I realized – this keeps happening again and again – and my black brothers and sisters keep pleading, “Grant us justice against our adversary.” And I simply remain silent, or make excuses, or turn the channel, or stop the video and go back to what I always do – live a life without fear because I am not black. And I wonder, might their prayers for justice or even vengeance be against me? And it’s not simply police violence but the overall rate of Covid infections among the black community, their lack of access to hospitals and medical care, the utter lack of equity and justice in the system. And as I got lost in all this pain, I heard Jesus ask me a question, “When I return, what will I find?”


Finally, remember that parables are “faith on the earth” stories and that prayer is a “faith on the earth” practice. [Reading Action]
It’s fascinating to note that Jesus’ parable on prayer doesn’t end with the question, “When the Son of Man comes, will he find prayer on the earth, or find you more thoughtful, or discover that you’re nice? Jesus’ parable asks one direct question: “Will I find you more faithful “on the earth”; that is, in this life, at this time, in this place?” It’s interesting that in a parable on prayer Jesus concludes with faith. And not just any faith but “faith on this earth” – faith in this life, faith that matters, faith that is about justice. “Faith on the earth” is the point. Friends, it’s more than a question of whether Jesus will find “faith.” Will people as well? Will widows and orphans? Will George Floyd and Ahmaud Arbery?
Peaceful persistent prayer and acting justly are ‘the faith” God expects to find. “Faith,” according to Jesus, is a “lived conviction” – not perfectly, not without being bathed in grace but lived nonetheless and is the true thermometer of our prayer life. Faith is the coming together of prayer and justice “on the earth.” It means more than that we pray for justice but also that we pray that we act justly. So I want you to join in me that prayer. I’m going to be starting another group that will be doing just that – praying, reading, talking, acting – toward greater justice for our black brothers and sisters – that Jesus calls faith. I want to invite you to join me in it so that when Jesus comes our “faith will be found” and we won’t have a black eye.

No comments: